Panas’s recent win over Hen Hud had me thinking about this year’s most surprising upsets. Is it just me or have there been more this year than in recent seasons? That’s a good thing, at least from a reporter’s perspective. Parity and unpredictablity makes for better viewing. It’s definitely been the case with Section 1 football, where the 42-0 drubbings that were standard are suddenly very rare.
But back to soccer. There’s been enough upsets that I feel the urge to create a deliciously ubiquitous top 10 list. Some of these were off the top of my head, though it took some research to fill out the list. It’s a virtual certainty that someone got left out. So please, let me know if I forgot your team and maybe I’ll release an updated list later.
10. Pearl River 0, Albertus Magnus 0, Oct. 16: A couple years ago this would have been a premier matchup and a typical result. Not so in 2007, when the Pirates (6-9-1), already in a transition year, were beset by injuries. Shauna Conroy made nine saves to keep Albertus (11-4-1) off the board.ÂÂ
9. New Rochelle 3, Clarkstown North 1, Sept. 29: New Rochelle has one win and one tie all season, and both made this list. Nora Haney scored twice to push the Huguenots (1-7-1) past a decent North (7-7) squad.
8. Rye 3, Eastchester 1, Oct. 2: It may not look like a big deal now that Rye (9-6-1) is second in League 3-B and Eastchester (9-4-2) is fourth, but at the time the Eagles were riding high at 6-1-1 while the Garnets were 2-6. Rye would go on to sweep the season series. (On a side note, Rye hasn’t lost in the month of October. Look out Pelham!)
7. Ossining 2, Nyack 1, Oct. 15: Nyack has provided a few head-scratchers, good and bad. Even though the Indians (9-7) haven’t lived up to their own expectations, they’re still pretty good. So how do you explain a loss to Ossining (3-11), which to that point had seven goals in 11 games? ÂÂ
6. Lakeland 2, Nyack 1, Sept. 27: This game was the subject of much excitement among Lakeland’s hungry players. Kristen Reiche had 15 saves for the Hornets (3-12), who, in part because of a vicious league, followed the win with 11 straight losses.
5. Fox Lane 0, John Jay 0, Oct. 11: Coming off a near-miss against Somers and a 5-3 loss to Yorktown, the Foxes (5-8-1) salvaged something at John Jay (9-3-2).
4. New Rochelle 1, Mahopac 1, Sept. 25: New Ro scored first, then hung on against a Mahopac (9-5-2) team that would go on to win five of its next six.
3. Panas 1, Hen Hud 0, Oct. 18: Desperately needing a win to stay in the playoff hunt, Panas (7-10) got a second-half goal from Erin Donohue and 16 saves from Tiara Johnson—Hen Hud coach Eileen Cancro called her “awesome”—to throw a stop sign in front of the streaking Sailors (10-5).
2. Mahopac 2, Arlington 1, Oct. 9: Arlington was 11-0 when Mahopac made the trip north. The Indians had taken a step in the right direction by beating Ketcham a few days earlier, but that was nothing compared to this win. Carly Villanova scored twice in the second half.
1. Clarkstown South 1, Nanuet 0, Oct. 13: If you’ve followed this blog or Section 1, you might have seen No. 1 coming. If only Nanuet (16-1) could have borrowed some of that foresight. On a homecoming Saturday morning, Taylor Quilty’s direct kick in the final minute provided the season’s most improbable result. It was only South’s (6-9) fourth shot on net. By Wednesday we’ll likely be looking back on it as the only thing between Nanuet and a perfect regular season.